Thursday, July 08, 2010

A "Miracle" in Chakwal, Pakistan?

It is great that miracles usually stay within ones own religion. So for example, images of Jesus or Mary usually only appear to Christians and Islamic miracles (usually with no human images) appear only to Muslims (and respectively for other religions as well). There usually is no cross-over confusion. I would say that this religious bifurcation of miracles, by in itself, is quite a miracle. For a taste, check out this very funny (and relevant) compilation of Jesus sightings and here is an example of Allah written on a piece of meat.

Pervez Hoodbhoy recently encountered such a claim of a miracle in Chakwal, Pakistan. Here is his take on the issue (it also appeared in Dawn in May of this year):

Is Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) in Chakwal?
 Pervez Hoodbhoy

The sudden appearance of Prophet Mohammed’s (PBUH) alleged footprint in the sleepy village of Dharabi near Chakwal has sent a wave of religious excitement across Pakistan. At a three-hour drive from Islamabad, Dharabi is now attracting tens of thousands of visitors from Swat to Karachi. They seek blessings, spiritual enlightenment, miracle-cures, and relief from life’s other stresses. A road that is sparsely traveled in normal times is now clogged with traffic, vendors of food and drink are having a field day, new businesses selling pictures and holy paraphernalia have sprouted, and a permanent shrine is under construction. The village could not have hoped for better.

My encounter in mid-March with this phenomenon was accidental and preceded the heavy rush that came in subsequent weeks. While on the way to Chakwal, I became curious about the heavy police presence. Upon inquiring, I was told of a recent momentous event – a giant footprint was said to have suddenly appeared, which the local ulema promptly declared as belonging to the Holy Prophet. But this had ignited a fierce war of words between various religious factions in the larger Chakwal area. Some believers insist that the Prophet had left the earthly world once and forever, while others contend that he revisits it periodically to remind followers of his presence. The police had been called to prevent physical violence.

Conversations over tea with the Dharabi’s inhabitants gave me some facts. However, the entire story soon receded to the back of my mind. It was revived several weeks later when it hit the national press and television. To augment my understanding I made phone calls to several villagers I had met, but discovered that new embellishments and inventions are being added by the day to the original narration of events. Village skeptics, on the other hand, are being silenced and speak only on the condition that their identities not be revealed.

The story begins on 12th Rabi-ul-Awwal, the Prophet’s birthday, when celebrations were held as per village custom. This involves cooking sooji ka halwa in large flat iron dishes called karahis. Since there are no stoves large enough for the purpose, shallow holes are dug and then filled with twigs, charcoal, or other flammable material. After the cooking is done and the fires had dimmed, the holes are filled with loose earth. On that particular evening, I learned that there was a heavy rain shower. 

And now the story goes like this: that evening a woman looked out into her backyard and saw a glow that appeared to move. In her excitement, she summoned her mother-in-law who says she also saw the glow. It appeared very briefly and was not seen subsequently (although a six-week later version is that it lasted for three days and was so bright that the house did not need electric lights!). The women also claimed that the glow was accompanied by a sweet smell. In the morning, the cooking area was discovered to have a mysterious ground impression. The rest is history.

What scientific explanation exists for this phenomenon? As a starter, readers of this article are invited to Google the “Dharabi miracle” where they will see countless uploads of photographs and hastily made celebratory videos. By straining one’s imagination, some may be able to see a footprint. But its enormous size – between 3-4 feet long – would indicate that it belongs to the long-sought mythical Himalayan Yeti rather than any human. The shape of the impression can be more plausibly explained as that of loose earth, brought together by rainwater, from two adjacent irregularly rounded cooking holes. It could also be the water-distorted image of two heavy round karhai’s of different sizes placed on the soft earth. Or it could simply be deliberate fraud.

Assuming that the women had their wits about them, and had not been overpowered by the devotional intensity of the day’s celebrations, the softly glowing ephemeral light could have multiple explanations. First, it is possible that a swarm of phosphorescent insects was somehow attracted to the cooking area. Bioluminescence in insects is a well known phenomenon. As in the common firefly known as jugnoo, “cold light” is produced via chemiluminescence.

It could also be that the organic matter buried in the holes, assisted by the heat of imperfectly quenched coals or twigs, could have converted into methane and phosphine gases. The latter is known to oxidize spontaneously upon coming into contact with air and can burn at a low temperature causing glowing light. Appearances of apparitions in western folklore, such as Jack-o'-the-Lantern or Will-o'-the-Wisp, have been traced by scientists to various flammable gases and insects.

A detailed investigation would involve looking at the soil composition, local entomology, and recorded statements of different witnesses. It seems, however, that the Dharabi event will be ignored by Pakistan’s scientific institutions, of which there are well over two dozen. With exorbitant budgets but zero or little scientific output, some are housed in shiny new buildings on Islamabad’s Constitution Avenue. These include the Pakistan Academy of Sciences, Committee on Science and Technology in the Islamic World (COMSTECH), COMSATS, Pakistan Science Foundation, Pakistan Council on Science and Technology, etc.

Unfortunately not one of the above or, for that matter, any other Pakistani scientific institute, has ever debunked the unreasonable and anti-scientific attitudes that one sees all around. For example, after the October 2005 earthquake that killed nearly 100,000, none challenged the view in the public media that this tragedy was a consequence of our bad deeds such as, for example, watching television or allowing unveiled women to go out of the house. 

To be sure, superstitious beliefs exist in other countries as well. One recalls the hysteria in 1995 following the discovery that Lord Ganesh, the Elephant God, would “drink” milk if a spoon of milk was held up to his trunk. Even minor temples in India overflowed with superstitious devotees. So great was the rush of devotees that a traffic gridlock resulted in New Delhi and sales of milk jumped up by 30%.

Fortunately for India, an independent body, the Indian Rationalists Association, was quick to show that Ganesh’s milk drinking had a simple physical explanation. It was shown to be simple capillary action – what everyone learns about in school science books. The surface tension of the milk was pulling the liquid up and out of the spoon, before gravity caused it to run down the front of the statue. To its credit, India’s Ministry of Science and Technology confirmed the explanation and the country’s religious craziness slowly abated. With such precedents, surely it is time for Pakistan’s Ministry of Science and Technology to investigate the so-called Chakwal miracle, as well as the many similar superstitions that delude our people and keep them in a state of stupor and backwardness.

POSTSCRIPT: After this article was published in Dawn on 18 May 2010, the police authorities in Chakwal telephoned me to say that my version of events was accurate. Moreover, the authorities had poured cement upon the alleged footprint but “miraculously” it had been removed by some divine agency the very next morning. Mr. Tanvir’s house, which houses the phenomenon, had a market value of Rs 250,000 a few months earlier but has just been sold at Rs. 2,000,000. He, and those of his family members who claim to have witnessed the light, have become pirs and pirnis with people queuing up for days to receive blessings. The family has hit the jackpot.

 The author is professor of physics at Quaid-e-Azam University, Islamabad


Dr. M. Akbar Hussain said...

What I fail to understand is that why on Earth is such a story being given so much attention? Such things happen on yearly basis...if not monthly or weekly in Pakistan and deserve to be ignored totally. The truth of the matter is...I only came to know about this hoax through Hoodbhoy himself in his article on

Salman Hameed said...


I think this is a fascinating question. On the one hand, I agree with you that there is nothing intellectually interesting in the story - and by reporting on it simply gives it more publicity. I often feel the same way about creationism stories in the US. On the other hand, I can also see the importance of the promotion of skepticism and critical thinking - especially in places where pseudoscience is more a norm than an exception. In that sense, I appreciate, at least some people writing on these matters. In fact, such opportunities become an opportunity for promoting critical thinking (and Pervez does so in his article). I wish Pakistan had a skeptical organization - to regularly deal with such claims. I know that India also has the same problem, but there the skeptical movement is relatively more visible.

CATGIRL said...

Hey dear! I am a female MBA from Karachi, Pakistan. Love ur blog outlook and ur awesome thoughts. Best of Luck for ur blogging. I hope we can be mutual followers- if u like my blog?? And don’t forget to comment please !!

Ali said...

Hi Salman,

I've read only your intro to your article about the miracle of Chakwal. But today I've Googled for it and I found this.

I think you will like it. :)

"I wish Pakistan had a skeptical organization - to regularly deal with such claims."

Looks like you have been living abroad for too long. (I nearly said this yesterday but thought I will keep quiet. :))

RBH said...

It is great that miracles usually stay within ones own religion. So for example, images of Jesus or Mary usually only appear to Christians and Islamic miracles (usually with no human images) appear only to Muslims (and respectively for other religions as well). There usually is no cross-over confusion.

That reminds me of a possibly fictional claim I first heard four decades ago in graduate school, to the effect that the patients of psychotherapists tend to have dreams that are consistent with the orientation of their therapists. So patients of Freudian therapists have Freudian dreams, patients of Jungian therapists have Jungian dreams, and so on. Presumably the patients of therapists who use behavior modification don't dream. :)

Salman Hameed said...

Thanks Ali - this is great! Good for Waqt News. BUt some of the comments were also making me wonder if this also has to do with Deobandies (who don't believe in such things from a religious perspective) and Barelvis (who believe in such visitations).


Of course, we all know that behavioral therapists don't dream... :)

Dr. M. Akbar Hussain said...

LOL! Salman, you r getting attention and appreciation from a different perspective too. Good luck :-)
...So when you are visiting Karachi? ;-)

Ali said...

"... Deobandies (who don't believe in such things from a religious perspective) and Barelvis (who believe in such visitations)."

I don't have a clue.
I think in this case, someone did a prank and it became too big even for his liking.

"...So when you are visiting Karachi? ;-)"

Soon, now that he has more than astronomy to explore there. :)

Salman Hameed said...

"...So when you are visiting Karachi? ;-)"

"Soon, now that he has more than astronomy to explore there. :)"